Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

Potential Energy


Kevin Bullis is Technology Review’s energy editor.

Recent Posts

Blog Topics

Recent Comments

  • DJTal : ........ Apparently the people of Dubai don't get the Flintstones humour .......... but the...
  • gabrielg01 : easy answer: both are immoral.
  • skingw : in your link of logic, one missing part is the people who happily uses one or two nice SUV  while...
  • ... : This measure would only be needed while there were still combustion engine vehicles on the roads....
  • gabrielg01 : This seems very unfair. Most hybrid vehicles on the road today, when moving at low speeds use...
  • gabrielg01 : So, Masdar the zero emission project will be ok, because Abu Dhabi's oil money can finance the...
  • jrd1415 : Quiet is good, don't screw it up.  Profquatermass got it right, with just the sort of creative...
  • dmm : I have never understood why EVERY car horn doesn't have a "hey you" mode, to be used to politely...
  • Cheetahman : A new open standard is needed. This standard should allow cars to share information with cars...
  • mthomason : Just imagine you're in bumper-to-bumper traffic on the freeway and everyone's EV was...
Advertisement
Monday, August 03, 2009

Nissan Reveals "Leaf" Electric Car for 2010

Will the vehicle's short range hamper its success?
By Kevin Bullis

Last week Nissan showed off the battery and drivetrain platform for its upcoming electric vehicle. Now it's revealed the car itself--the Leaf.

This zero-emissions vehicle, which has a range of 100 miles on a charge, will go on sale next year in Japan, the United States, and Europe. It will be powered by a lithium manganese battery developed in a joint venture between Nissan and NEC. Manganese-based lithium ion batteries are popular with automakers (GM plans to use one in the Volt) because they're more stable than the cobalt oxide batteries commonly used in laptops and other portable electronics.

Nissan is taking a markedly different strategy than companies such as Toyota, GM, and Chrysler, which have emphasized hybrid vehicles that can run on both electricity and gasoline. Even the Volt, which GM is describing as an electric vehicle, has an onboard gasoline generator that kicks in after 40 miles of driving to recharge its battery. Because gasoline stores orders of magnitude more energy than batteries, such vehicles can have longer range than pure battery electric vehicles like Nissan's Leaf. What's more, fuel tanks can be refilled much faster than batteries can be recharged, at least without special electrical connections, making long-distance road trips easier. (Electric vehicle enthusiasts like to brag about cross-country trips, but these require careful planning--it's good to find RV parks equipped with 220-volt outlets--and a willingness to take frequent breaks while the car charges.)

Nissan has been working with a company called Better Place on a strategy for extending the range of EVs. The idea is to build battery swap stations along major highways. Drive in and a simple robot takes out your car's depleted battery and inserts a charged one, and you're quickly on your way again. Nissan demonstrated one version of a swap station in May.

But it wasn't immediately clear whether the Leaf would be compatible with swap stations. A spokesperson for Nissan said that the company doesn't plan to use a swap strategy in the United States, but she expects the Leaf could be used with swap stations in other countries. She said she'd get back to me to confirm. (If she does, I'll add that here.)

Many EV supporters say it doesn't make sense to buy a car with a gasoline engine and fuel tank as well as an electric motor and battery pack. After all, most of the time either one or the other is just dead weight, sitting there unused. They say, if you commute less than 80 miles each day, buy an EV. Then, for those relatively rare occasions when a longer range is required, rent a car. Or use the EV as a second vehicle.

But one of the most expensive parts of an EV is the battery, and most people actually commute less than 40 miles a day. If you can make do with a battery pack half the size, you could save money, even with the added cost of a gasoline generator. So either strategy--pure EV or hybrid--could make sense.

Comments

  • Scalable Batteries
    Seems like they could design the battery system to scale pretty easily. My commute is only 34 miles round trip, so I could get by with a 40 or 50 mile battery pack. Someone with a 10 mile RT commute could use an even smaller pack, and someone with a longer commute could have a bigger one. I don't know exactly how the cells are wired, but they could probably set it up to have several sets connected in parallel, so you could just use the number of sets you need to get the range you need. Could save a fair bit of money upfront, and then a bit longer term, as well (they probably don't weigh enough to impact range, but the replacement cost would be affected).
    Rate this comment: 12345

    KevinFink
    08/03/2009
    Posts:1
    Avg Rating:
    5/5
  • Scalable Batteries
    Instead of renting a second car, perhaps one could rent an additional battery pack for longer drives?
    Rate this comment: 12345

    eyewire
    08/03/2009
    Posts:3
    Avg Rating:
    5/5
    • Re: Scalable Batteries
      Exactly!  Provide the means to bring along an extra battery only when needed.  Or the means to swap out the small battery, and install a larger battery for those longer trips.
      <br>
      For that matter, battery technology will have improved in a few years, so provide the means to trade up to a better battery  when the new technology becomes available.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      billcoleman
      08/04/2009
      Posts:1
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
      • Re: Scalable Batteries
        How about a slide-in gas powered electric generator module with an enclosed small gas tank? That way the weight of the generator isn't carried when not needed.
        Rate this comment: 12345

        eyewire
        08/04/2009
        Posts:3
        Avg Rating:
        5/5
  • electrify turnpikes
    Maybe time to think about laying electric lines in turnpike roads / HOV lanes and all these vehicles outfitted with the same induction pickup system. These pickup units would record power consumed and you would pay the charge at the toll booth with the road usage fee as usual. So vehicles would not need extra batteries and no battery stations would be required. Probably much better for the environment. This mitigates the problem of battery stations having to be designed to provide a myriad of battery types and their potential obsolescence with future battery technologies.
    The vehicle batteries could top off while driving these roads. The wire system only needs be in one lane since the vehicles can still travel on batteries when passing. Localized power generation of wind / solar or grid where required could power the system.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    flyingmonste...
    08/04/2009
    Posts:6
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
  • Zero Emissions
    These vehicles may have zero emissions at the tailpipe (or have no tailpipe for that matter...), but they are NOT zero emissions vehicles.  That electricity has to come from somewhere, and there are emissions associated with EVERY form of electrical generation.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    MITBeta
    08/04/2009
    Posts:29
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
    • Re: Zero Emissions
      Are you talking about the magic hole in the wall? I've never seen any exhaust pipe in one of those!
      Rate this comment: 12345

      Quarnel
      08/04/2009
      Posts:1
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
    • Re: Zero Emissions
      The car is zero emissions, you don't know that every scrap of energy isn't coming from solar in his back yard.

      The electricity to charge may come from a source that creates emissions, but that's not the fault of the car.

      Even if it does come from a dirty source, that source can be cleaned up, or changed and EVs use that cleanup 100%, whereas other choices do add emissions.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      asdar
      08/04/2009
      Posts:69
      Avg Rating:
      4/5
      • Re: Zero Emissions
        I do know with a high degree of certainty that "every scrap" of energy is NOT coming from "his" backyard solar panel since electrons flow from high voltage to low voltage with no regard for source or sink.

        But even if it did, there are still emissions associated with the manufacturing, delivery, and installation of solar panels.  Calling a car "zero emissions" is simple obfuscation.
        Rate this comment: 12345

        MITBeta
        08/04/2009
        Posts:29
        Avg Rating:
        4/5
  • Easy Range Extension
    One easy fix for extending range would be a battery trailer.  Design the car to have a plug in module at the back and the ability to tow 200 to 500 lbs.  Then for longer drives you could rent the trailer, and swap at designated places like U-Haul or some other vendor.  Properly done, it would take 3 minutes to drive in, swap trailers and then be on your merry way.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    tsaidak
    08/04/2009
    Posts:16
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
  • misplaced use of battery material
    I think it's a mistake to go for 100% EV right now, even though I do like EV with a generator.

    The reason that's most compelling to me is the use of expensive battery material.

    Take this one for instance. If you cut the material in half you have two cars that  would cover almost 90% of auto usage. That's saving almost double the gas. There's no way around this simple number to my way of thinking.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    asdar
    08/04/2009
    Posts:69
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
  • Useful as is.
    We're retired, and we have two cars. One is a hybrid, fine for long trips. We would like to have a vehicle like this for around town use, because it would be easy to keep it charged, and its maintenance and charge costs would be so low. Currently our second car is a middle-aged Miata. Great car--but it cost over $500 to fix an EGR valve related problem.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Olaf
    08/04/2009
    Posts:3
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
  • Environment -vs - comfort
    I've yet to see an electric-only design that gives priority to passenger comfort.  What's the range on this thing with the AC going full-blast?  When it's 100 degrees plus outside, a fan alone just turns it into a convection oven. This may work for mild climates, but not in the  warmer areas of the US.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    dnwdfw
    08/04/2009
    Posts:16
    Avg Rating:
    4/5
  • [no subject]

    An affordable, normal-looking, 100% electric car? This is a dream come true. Electric cars are safe, clean, efficient. This is a really big step towards reducing greenhouse gases, lessening the impact of peak oil, and saving money in the process. American auto companies need to learn from Nissan on this one! I just finished reading “Two Cents Per Mile” by Nevres Cefo, which is the most informative book I’ve read on the topic, and I suggest it to anyone interested in electric cars. You could also read portions of it on Amazon.com.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    evlover
    08/10/2009
    Posts:2
    Avg Rating:
    5/5
Advertisement

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement
Technology Review November/December 2009

Current Issue

Natural Gas Changes the Energy Map
The United States has vast supplies of this cleaner fossil fuel. But how should we use it?
•  Subscribe
Save 36%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News
» Gift Subscription
» Digital Subscription
» Reprints, Back Issues
» Subscribe
» Table of Contents
» MIT News

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.