Technology Review - Published By MIT
Advertisement

arXiv blog

The Physics arXiv Blog produces daily coverage of the best new ideas from an online forum called the Physics arXiv on which scientists post early versions of their latest ideas. Contact me at KentuckyFC @ arxivblog.com

Email Subscription

Recently on the arXiv blog...

Recent comments on the arXivblog

  • flared0ne : The best analysis likely here is going to be along the lines of an opportunity cost model. I've...
  • spad12 : Main Entry: 1 loan Pronunciation: \'lonFunction: noun Etymology: Middle English lon, from Old...
  • ... : I agree with the statement that you need to take some econ courses. You don't change the cost of...
  • ... : These 'known reserves' are simply unaudited projections that make it to the Red Book, AKA the Red...
  • ... : I was going to reply to the prior entry, Bob, but you beat me to it. Those promoting loan...
  • ... : The assumption that creativity and imitation are exclusive activities (or accomplishments) is...
  • bugmenot2 : Quantum computers are excellent at simulating quantum systems, exponentially faster than...
  • Ron Diehl : Replace the word "quantum computer" with "human brain", and your response makes equal sense. What...
  • kjblack : I,m glad that I won't be around to see the future squabble into energy generation and water...
  • kvj : China is going to construct 100 NPPs. U.S. 30. Even middle east countries are going to construct...
  • ms : I'm surprised you didn't mention that rig a is just a doubling-up of each position in the Italian...
  • tulcod : The "promise" given in the first paragraph is completely irrealistic. It's not number crunching...
  • ... : Well, I did log in and searched in vain for your "withering reply".  Is it perhaps subtly hidden...
  • TooMany : While the anti-nuke contingent in the US and in parts of Europe continues to rant about the...
  • mulliguns : Points to why a pair may be the most difficult to row successfully, and that sometimes odd size...
  • shaase : It would seem difficult to guarantee that oarsmen all pull with the same force, so it will still...
  • seth : Even though the new arrangements were not immediately obvious, I do think they make common sense....
  • ... : I have examined the major uranium producing countries and made a forecast for 2009, 2010 and...
  • ZephirAWT : Frankly, I don't believe in communication hypothesis wery much, but there's is at least another...
  • ... : http://www.technologyreview.com/energy/22114/The link above goes to your Technology Review...
Advertisement
Friday, May 29, 2009

Altruism Repays the Best-Connected Individuals

Unselfish behaviour spreads through society in a way that most benefits the "hubs" in the network.

How altruistic behaviour emerges has puzzled evolutionary biologists for decades. From the point of view of survivial of the fittest, the unselfish concern for the welfare of others seems inexplicable. Surely any organism should always act selfishly if it were truly intent on saving its own bacon.

One explanation is that altruistic acts, although seemingly unselfish, actually benefit those who perform them but in indirect ways. The idea is that unselfish acts are repeated. So those who have been helped go on to help other individuals, ensuring that this behaviour spreads through a group, a phenomenon known as upstream reciprocity.

Eventually, the individual that triggered the altruistic behaviour will be on the receiving end of least one unselfish act, ensuring that, at the very least, he or she doesn't lose out. In this way, unselfish individuals actually benefit from their altruism.

At least, that's the theory. While other types of altruism have been observed and modelled (for example downstream reciprocity in which people help others who they have seen acting altruistically), upstream reciprocity has proven harder to pin down, until now

Akio Iwagami and Naoki Masuda at the University of Tokyo have simulated the way upstream reciprocity spreads through a network when the behaviour gradually dies out. It turns out that the type of network is crucial for ensuring the spread of the behaviour. In heterogeneous networks like those that most societies seem to form, upstream reciprocity seems to spread successfully.

But interestingly, Iwagami and Masuda point out that certain individuals seem to benefit more than others. These individuals are "hubs" in these societies, people who have many links to other individuals. That makes sense, of course, because as this behaviour spreads, it is much more likely to pass through hubs than other points on the network.

So the moral of the story is that if you want to benefit from altruistic behaviour, do two things. First, trigger altruistic cascades by performing many acts of unselfish behaviour. Second, become a hub with lots of links to other indviduals.

Ref: arxiv.org/abs/0905.4007: Upstream Reciprocity in Heterogeneous Networks

Comments

  • Richard Dawkins
    I was under the impression that Richard Dawkins in "The Selfish Gene" demonstrated why pure selfishness doesn't always yield the most beneficial results.
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Derrekito
    05/30/2009
    Posts:1
    Avg Rating:
    5/5
    • Re: Richard Dawkins
      No, in The Selfish Gene Dawkins showed (among other things) how 'selfish' genes could produce cooperative behavior in the phenotypes that carry the genes. As he has said, he could have titled the book The Cooperative Gene with no change in content.
      Rate this comment: 12345

      RBH
      06/01/2009
      Posts:1
      Avg Rating:
      5/5
  • Movie Stars 'n' Billionaires
    THis is interesting. In human society, wealthy movers 'n' shakers tend to be hubs, whereas the proles not so much. I always used to think that the high profile altruists in the newspapers were doing it out of the kindness of their hearts (and because they've got extra money to burn). But according to the above analysis, the high profilers of all people stand to benefit the most from their own altruistic acts. How very disenchanting. . . .
    Rate this comment: 12345

    Warren Platt...
    06/20/2009
    Posts:1
Advertisement

Log In

Forgot your password?     Register »
Advertisement
Technology Review November/December 2009

Current Issue

Natural Gas Changes the Energy Map
The United States has vast supplies of this cleaner fossil fuel. But how should we use it?
•  Subscribe
Save 36%
•  Table of Contents
•  MIT News
» Gift Subscription
» Digital Subscription
» Reprints, Back Issues
» Subscribe
» Table of Contents
» MIT News

More Technology News from Forbes

Advertisement
MIT Massachusetts Institute of Technology © 2009 Technology Review. All Rights Reserved.